Al Kaline, DET | 13 |
| Don
Drysdale, LA | 8 |
| Jim Wilson, CHI | 3 |
| Richie Ashburn, PHI | 4 | Al Rosen, CLE | 4 |
| Don
Mueller, NY | 2 |
| Jimmie Hall, MIN | 2 |
| Roberto
Clemente, PIT | 8 | Al
Smith, CHI | 2 |
| Don Newcombe, BKN | 2 |
| Joe
Nuxhall, CIN | 2 |
| Robin Roberts, PHI | 6 | Allie Reynolds, NY | 3 |
| Duke
Snider, BKN | 7 |
| Joe Pepitone, NY | 3 |
| Rocky
Colavito, DET | 6 | Alvin
Dark, NY | 3 |
| Earl Battey, MIN | 4 |
| Joe
Torre, ATL | 5 |
| Rod Carew, MIN | 2 | Andy Etchebarren, BAL | 2 |
| Early
Wynn, CLE | 6 |
| Johnny Antonelli, SF | 5 |
| Roger
Maris, NY | 4 | Art
Mahaffey, PHI | 2 |
| Ed Bailey, SF | 5 |
| Johnny
Callison, PHI | 3 |
| Ron Hunt, NY | 2 | Bill Freehan, DET | 5 |
| Eddie
Mathews | 9 |
| Johnny Edwards, CIN | 3 |
| Ron
Santo, CHI | 5 | Bill
Mazeroski, PIT | 7 |
| Eddie Robinson, PHI | 3 |
| Johnny
Logan | 4 |
| Roy Campanella, BKN | 6 | Bill Monbouquette, BOS | 3 |
| Elston
Howard, NY | 9 |
| Johnny Podres, LA | 3 |
| Roy
Face, PIT | 3 | Bill
Skowron, CHI | 6 |
| Enos Slaughter, STL | 3 |
| Johnny
Roseboro, LA | 2 |
| Roy McMillan, CIN | 2 | Bill White, STL | 5 |
| Ernie
Banks, CHI | 10 |
| Johnny Temple, CLE | 4 |
| Roy
Sievers, CHI | 4 | Billy
O'dell, BAL | 2 |
| Felipe Alou, SF | 3 |
| Juan Marichal, SF | 7 |
| Rusty
Staub, HOU | 2 | Billy
Pierce, CHI | 7 |
| Ferris Fain, PHI | 4 |
| Juan
Pizarro, CHI | 2 |
| Ryne Duren, NY | 3 | Billy Williams, CHI | 4 |
| Frank
Bolling | 2 |
| Julian Javier, STL | 2 |
| Sal
Maglie, NY | 2 | Bob
Allison | 3 |
| Frank Lary, DET | 2 |
| Ken
Boyer, STL | 7 |
| Sam Jones, SF | 2 | Bob Friend, PIT | 3 |
| Frank
Malzone, BOS | 6 |
| Ken McBride, LA | 3 |
| Sam
McDowell, CLE | 3 | Bob
Gibson, STL | 5 |
| Frank Robinson, CIN | 8 |
| Larry
Doby, CLE | 5 |
| Sandy Koufax, LA | 6 | Bob Lemon, CLE | 4 |
| Frank
Sullivan, BOS | 2 |
| Larry Jackson, STL | 4 |
| Satchel
Paige, STL | 2 | Bob
Purkey, CIN | 3 |
| Frank Thomas, PIT | 3 |
| Leo
Cardenas, CIN | 4 |
| Sherm Lollar, CHI | 6 | Bob Skinner, PIT | 2 |
| Gary
Peters, CHI | 2 |
| Leon Wagner, LA | 2 |
| Smoky
Burgess, PIT | 6 | Bob
Turley, BAL | 3 |
| Gene Alley, PIT | 2 |
| Lew
Burdette | 2 |
| Stan Musial, STL | 13 | Bob Veale, PIT | 2 |
| Gene
Conley, PHI | 3 |
| Luis Aparicio, CHI | 7 |
| Steve
Barber, BAL | 2 | Bobby
Avila, CLE | 3 |
| George A. Bell, CLE | 3 |
| Luis
Arroyo, STL | 2 |
| Ted Kluszewski, CIN | 4 | Bobby Richardson, NY | 7 |
| George
Altman, CHI | 2 |
| Maury Wills, LA | 5 |
| Ted
Williams, BOS | 9 | Bobby
Shantz, NY | 2 |
| George Kell, DET | 6 |
| Max
Alvis, CLE | 2 |
| Tim McCarver, STL | 2 | Brooks Robinson, BAL | 9 |
| Gerry
Staley, STL | 3 |
| Mel Stottlemyre, NY | 3 |
| Tom Haller, SF | 3 | Bud Daley | 2 |
| Gil
Hodges, BKN | 6 |
| Mickey Mantle, NY | 16 |
| Tom
Seaver, NY | 2 | Camilo
Pascual | 5 |
| Gil McDougald, NY | 5 |
| Mickey
Vernon, CLE | 5 |
| Tom Tresh, NY | 2 | Carl Furillo, BKN | 2 |
| Granny
Hamner, PHI | 3 |
| Mike Garcia, CLE | 3 |
| Tommie
Agee, CHI | 2 | Carl
Yastrzemski, BOS | 5 |
| Gus Triandos, BAL | 3 |
| Mike
McCormick, SF | 2 |
| Tommy Davis, LA | 2 | Catfish Hunter | 2 |
| Hal Smith, STL | 2 |
| Milt
Pappas, BAL | 2 |
| Tommy Helms, CIN | 2 | Charlie Maxwell, DET | 2 |
| Hank
Aaron, ATL | 14 |
| Minnie Minoso, CLE | 7 |
| Tony
Kubek, NY | 3 | Charlie
Neal, LA | 2 |
| Hank Bauer, NY | 3 |
| Mudcat
Grant, MIN | 2 |
| Tony Oliva, MIN | 5 | Chico Carrasquel, CHI | 4 |
| Harmon
Killebrew, MIN | 8 |
| Nellie Fox, CHI | 12 |
| Tony
Perez, CIN | 2 | Chris
Short, PHI | 2 |
| Harvey Kuenn, DET | 10 |
| Norm
Cash, DET | 2 |
| Turk Farrell, PHI | 4 | Clem Labine, BKN | 2 |
| Herb
Score, CLE | 2 |
| Norm Siebern | 2 |
| Vada Pinson, CIN | 2 | Curt Flood, STL | 3 |
| Hi
Bell, CIN | 4 |
| Orlando Cepeda, STL | 7 |
| Vic
Power, CLE | 2 | Curt
Simmons, PHI | 3 |
| Hoyt Wilhelm, NY | 4 |
| Pee
wee Reese, BKN | 4 |
| Vic Wertz, DET | 2 | Dean Chance, LA | 2 |
| Jackie
Jensen, BOS | 3 |
| Pete Richert | 2 |
| Wally
Moon, STL | 2 | Del
Crandall | 8 |
| Jackie Robinson, BKN | 4 |
| Pete
Rose, CIN | 3 |
| Warren Spahn, BOS | 11 | Del Ennis, PHI | 2 |
| Jim
Bunning, PHI | 7 |
| Pete Runnels, BOS | 3 |
| Wes
Westrum, NY | 2 | Denny
McLain, DET | 2 |
| Jim Finigan, PHI | 2 |
| Phil
Rizzuto, NY | 3 |
| Whitey Ford, NY | 8 | Dick Allen, PHI | 3 |
| Jim
Fregosi, LA | 4 |
| Preacher Roe, BKN | 2 |
| Willie
Horton, DET | 2 | Dick
Donovan | 3 |
| Jim Gentile, BAL | 3 |
| Ralph
Kiner, PIT | 3 |
| Willie Mays, SF | 15 | Dick Groat, STL | 5 |
| Jim
Gilliam, LA | 2 |
| Randy Jackson, CHI | 2 |
| Willie
McCovey, SF | 3 | Dick
McAuliffe, DET | 3 |
| Jim Hegan, CLE | 2 |
| Ray
Boone, DET | 2 |
| Willie Stargell, PIT | 3 | Dick Radatz, BOS | 2 |
| Jim
Kaat, MIN | 2 |
| Ray Narleski, CLE | 2 |
| Yogi
Berra, NY | 12 | Dom
Dimaggio, BOS | 2 |
| Jim Piersall, BOS | 2 |
| Red
Schoendienst, STL | 6 |
| Zoilo Versalles, MIN | 2 |
|